Moneyball
Bennett Miller
2011

Did I not love this like everyone else did because I know too much about the situation already? Is it because I know that it wasn’t really that big a deal what Beane did, and that you can actually do pretty well when you ride three fantastic pitchers to the playoffs a couple years in a row? And that when you get dropped in the first round AGAIN, everyone pats you on the head and says, “good work, with your numbers and stuff!” because your team doesn’t have any money?
I loved the tag at the end of the movie about how Theo Epstein won a World Series with the Red Sox just a year or two later using the exact same techniques Beane did. (Yeah, the exact same techniques, plus about a billion more dollars. It does make a difference. You can spend a lot of money really poorly, but you can also spend it intelligently, which Epstein did.)
Oh, the movie? It’s actually a lot of fun. C’mon, it’s baseball. And it’s Jonah Hill, who’s quite solid here. I just don’t think it’s this amazing movie that a whole bunch of other people think it is. It’s very good, and it’s worth seeing, but it’s not exactly special.
Here’s a very real possibility: I’m still pissed off that this is not Steven Soderbergh’s Moneyball. I completely admit that this could be why I’m feeling bitter about it.
But I also feel like movie geeks are overreacting a little bit here, and probably because the story sort of boils down to, “hey, the nerds beat the jocks!” That’s a time-honored storyline, and that’s fine. But I think that’s what’s really going on here.
You know whose team sucks now, and has for a good number of years? Billy Beane’s. It’s true. Is that because everyone started playing the same game as him, and the undervalued players were no longer undervalued? Or is it because he caught fire for a couple years (remember, according to this very movie, they went to the playoffs the year before he started this stuff) because his scouts built him a good farm system?
I understand the attraction of the storyline. It’s like playing the Warren Buffett investing strategy with baseball players. It’s nice to think things might work that way. And it’s not even that I think it’s bullshit, I just don’t think I’ve seen the evidence that tells me this approach is what worked.
Yes, I’m having a hard time separating my skepticism from the movie. I am. Also from the Steven Soderbergh thing.
What’s funny is that I liked the movie when I watched it, I think it’s just that all the praise is rubbing me the wrong way.
I really enjoyed the Art Howe stuff, especially knowing how he crashed and burned when he went to the Mets. At least he got paid, I guess.
The movie is good, but it could have been a lot better.